When we got married, I bought a simple white bone china set or a Korean tableware set at Namdaemun Market. I thought, “One set of dishes at home is enough,” but as I discovered the joy of cooking (though I’m still not very good at it), I naturally started wanting more dishes. Then I found Fishs Eddy, a dishware specialty store in Manhattan. I had only been browsing its website over and over, but when we visited CAMP in Flatiron with our daughter, I finally got to stop by the store I had wanted to go to. Yay!
Fishs Eddy is a restaurantware shop founded in 1986 by Julie Gaines and David Lenovitz, and its name is said to come from a small town in upstate New York. The store we visited is near Flatiron and Union Square. There are also stores in Chelsea Market and in DUMBO, Brooklyn.
A store like a treasure hunt
When you walk in, dishes are piled like mountains on an old wooden floor. Under a sign reading “Get Well Stacked,” white plates and bowls were stacked high, and small saucers were “Little Saucers 50¢ ea.”

A 16-inch platter was $5.99.


Colorful Nut Bowls were piled in a wooden barrel ($6.50).

The palette-shaped cheese tray I had seen on the website (Artist Palette, $75) was there in person. I wanted it, but I thought it would stand out too much next to the dishes we already have, and the price was steep, so I gave it up. It still lingers in my mind.

True to New York, there was a “Pigeons of NYC” corner with a pigeon drawing for each neighborhood, plus mugs and postcards.

The “Tunnel Vision” corner has a tote bag and a dish towel printed with “Manhattan Bridge,” plus mugs printed with New York and New Jersey signs.

There were also mugs printed with the faces of Lincoln and Benjamin Franklin.


The “Original Check!” corner has checkerboard-rimmed dishes. The store describes the pattern as part of its history and says it started from the checks seen in roadside diners in the 1930s. The official site also says the dishes appeared in Sex and the City, in the diner where the main characters meet.

Redband and Blueband
This is the Redband and Blueband collection, where our dishes came from: a corner with dishes and mugs ringed with thin red and blue lines.
I wanted to buy a set of the mugs, but they looked so ugly to me that I gave up.
We bought three fruit bowls, three salad bowls and three main plates, sized to our family. Maybe because they’re ceramic, they felt sturdy, thick and heavy, which I loved. The most expensive item, at $28, was a long hot dog plate. I bought just one and was happy with that.
The set is perfect for a diner feel at home! The downsides: I couldn’t buy a matching coffee cup set, and these dishes don’t suit the Korean food we usually eat.
When the website had 15% off a while back, I added a lot to my cart, and now I regret not buying then. Full price plus New York sales tax came to a good $200. Still, since we were visiting anyway, I treated myself.


The 40th anniversary tote bag
The staff asked if I needed a bag for the dishes, and when I said yes, they wrapped each plate in paper and put them into a Fishs Eddy tote bag. The bag says “EST. 1986” and “40 YEARS,” and the other side has an illustration of three tall stacks of plates. And $0.50 per bag shows up on the receipt.
Reviews I’ve read say the bag is a good souvenir and cheap, so you should ask for one, but the top cotton is too thin and the bottom is a burlap-sack-like material, so I don’t think it’s practical for everyday use.


